Howard zinn and paul johnson

Early life[ edit ] Zinn was born to a Jewish immigrant family in Brooklyn on August 24,

Howard zinn and paul johnson

Jan 04, Ethan Rose rated it did not like it This is more of a right wing conservative christian fairytale than a history book. The idea that we got out of the great depression because Roosevelt followed a plan that Hoover put into place before leaving office should come with some corroboration and support.

Also, I don't think pro choice advocates are equivalent to antebellum slavers. All histories are biased, I accept that, but some verification and cogent arguments would be appreciated.

This was obviously written to sway the ignorant mas This is more of a right wing conservative christian fairytale than a history book.

This was obviously written to sway the ignorant masses. A movement primer, the book shakes loose the bonds of fact and consistency to produce a narrative Kissinger describes on the book jacket as "majestic in its scope".

A History of the American People by Paul Johnson

Most of Paul Johnson's opus is great-man theory of history. The adoring descriptions of historical giants are fun. There are 2 problems: Calhoun gets Johnson's best great man BS. In just one paragraph p. Admittedly, large land holdings in the 18th century didn't guarantee wealth He died when Calhoun was 17, but the family wealth was sizable enough to finance a college education for the son.

As he moves into modern times, Johnson loses his mooring as internal self-contradictions and unsupported opinion become increasingly blatant. The right-wing Vietnam narrative emerges: This is a crucial update of the stab in the back for the modern conservative Of course, it's impossible to deny a hypothetical historical situation, forcing us sensible types to argue that had the US invaded North Vietnam, then China would probably have intervened just like in Korea Yet Johnson, reliable hack that he is, embraces the "Vietnam should have been won" thesis hard.

But he manages to totally contradict himself just 50 pages later. Pages of stab in the back narrative follow. And then on p. This kind of internal self-contradiction requires true movement-conservative grit. Us limp-wristed liberals would get all wimpy self-reflective if we wrote stuff like this.

We aren't built like Johnson. We need sterner wills to be as un-self-conscious as He. The only thing I really like about this book is its snooty English guy tone. Great men come from "good stock". Educated French phrases like pari pasu are tossed about. I don't even know what that means There's also an eye-opening throwaway line: If that's true, sheeeeeit.

Johnson's a decent writer. Keeping it relatively lively for a page history book is not easy. It's a kick save to 2 stars. The end is a truly lame wind up. It's all babbling nonsense about contemporary America. Half-assed opinion where PC professors and the living hell of Affirmative Action emerge as the most important socio-political developments in America.

The jacket writer, who probably avoided reading the book, had to strain to avoid writing the obvious: The jacket quotes the author - Paul Johnson - explaining that he does not seek to "conceal my opinions". In return, you get published and hyped. The bloggers call it "wingnut welfare" I don't know why I even read this stuff, except to learn the other side's assumptions.The respective approaches of Howard Zinn and Paul Johnson to early American history are almost diametrically opposite.

Johnson, as a staunch conservative, takes the colonists’ claims at face value. Paul Johnson and Howard Zinn have very different views of the American Revolution.

Paul Johnson is a conservative historian, while Howard Zinn is much more liberal in his thinking. Preliminary discussions have narrowed the choices down to either Howard Zinn’s "A People's History of the United States" or Paul Johnson’s "A History of the American People".

The NCHE Board wants a recommendation from you. Howard Zinn and Paul Johnson Howard Zinn, born August 24, , grew up in the slums of New York plombier-nemours.com recalls moving around a lot as his father ran candy stores during the Depression.

He graduated from Thomas Jefferson High School and became a pipe fitter in the Brooklyn Navy Yard. Howard Zinn and Paul Johnson.

Howard zinn and paul johnson

Howard Zinn and Paul Johnson Howard Zinn, born August 24, , grew up in the slums of New York City. He recalls moving around a lot as his father ran candy stores during the Depression. He graduated from Thomas Jefferson High School and became a pipe fitter in the Brooklyn Navy Yard.

Below is an essay on "Zinn and Johnson" from Anti Essays, your source for research papers, essays, and term paper examples. Book Comparison Intro: Howard Zinn and Paul Johnson are two Historians/5(1).

Howard Zinn and his opposite – à la Rob